Latest by Caroline Leavitt

With or Without YouWith or Without You by Caroline Leavitt
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

“With or Without You” is the latest by Caroline Leavitt and a welcome treat.

Stella, a nurse, and Simon, an aging musician, have remained a couple for two decades. As a result, their relationship has become stale and a bit predictable. Simon gets an opportunity to open for a younger musician in Los Angeles, which could lead to more shows and a “second coming” for his band. He asks Stella to accompany him on the gig, but Stella is not so sure it’s such a great idea. She’s thinking mortgages and babies while Simon is still thinking fame and stardom. She believes the days of dropping everything to chase a pipe dream are long past them.

A storm delays their flight as they continue to debate whether Stella should accompany Simon, their conversation fueled by alcohol. Stella is also nursing a cold, but trying to be agreeable, accepts a pill when Simon offers it because it was something they used to do in the past. The next morning, Simon wakes up with a bad hang over, but finds Stella unconscious.

Simon has to decide whether to go on the road or stay with Stella who slips into a coma. When Stella regains consciousness, her perception of the world is different. While she experiences issues remembering many things, she has a compulsion and obsession to draw. The pictures that Stella draws and paints improve.

I found this novel to be a nice distraction from the typical summer thrillers, which is not to say nothing happens in this story, but this novel’s focus is on movement within the characters and not outside events. I finished “With or Without You” in a handful of sittings because the writing was so engaging. Neither Simon nor Stella is necessarily likable, but that did not stop me from wanting to find out what would happen to them. It was because of the characters’ flaws that this tale was so intriguing. Ms. Leavitt has superb mastery of character and voice; her prose is lively but poignant. I am in utter awe of the author’s graceful depiction of how Stella’s (and Simon’s) lives are transformed. You have to wonder—if Stella had not ingested the pill, would this couple have been arguing about gigs and getting married in their sixties?

I'd like to thank NetGalley, Algonquin Books and the authors for providing me an advanced copy of this novel. “With or Without You” will be published on August 4, 2020.

View all my reviews

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A Great Historical Read

The Twist on the FairyTale

Hilarious Read